What is Ban the Box Legislation?
I am applying for jobs and the job application asks if I have been arrested.
Answer
Ban the Box Legislation refers to laws that require employers to not automatically dismiss a job applicant with arrests and criminal convictions. The employer must first consider an job applicant's qualifications for a position. These laws are indexed in legal materials under terms such as fair employment or discrimination. Some New York municipalities also have local laws that incorporate the New York State law.
New York State Ban the Box Legislation: Executive Law § 296 (16) ; New York Corrections Law, Art 23-A Licensure and Employment of Persons Previously convicted of One or More Criminal Offenses.
See the following legal materials for further discussion:
§ 6:12. Restrictions upon use of or obtaining criminal history record, 13A N.Y. Prac, Employment Law in New York § 6:12 (2d ed.) (Westlaw)
2 New York Employment Law § 24.12 (2nd 2021) Discrimination Based on Arrests or Conviction (Lexis)
The New York City Commission on Human Rights has published a valuable pamphlet. Criminal History? You can Work with That: A Worker's Guide to Criminal History Protections Under the New York City Human Rights Law describes what questions an employer may ask on a job application and during a job interview. The pamphlet also details some of the jobs that do require on criminal record searches. The pamphlet can be found through the link below.
Links & Files
- New York State Laws Opens in new window
- NY State Div of Human Rights Pamphlet: Protections Under the Law for People with Arrest and Conviction Records Opens in new window
- Buffalo Municipal Code, Ch 154 Discrimination, Art V Fair Employment Screening Opens in new window
- NYC Commission on Human Rights Pamphlet (16 pages): Criminal History? You Can Work with That Opens in new window
- New York City Fair Chance Act Opens in new window
- Rochester "Ban the Box" Ordinance Opens in new window
- National Employment Law Project: Ban the Box Opens in new window
- Suffolk County Human Rights Commission Opens in new window
- Suffollk County "Ban the Box" Ordinance Opens in new window
- Westchester County Human Rights Commission Opens in new window
- Westchester County Human Rights Law ยง700.03(a)(10) ("Ban the Box" Ordinance) Opens in new window